Not too long ago the soft, somber
undertones of the smallest fiddle in the world could be heard playing in the
background to Bill Clinton’s depictions of the hardships of
his upbringing. Today we are being serenaded by the mellow and solemn tones
of the smallest Stradivarius in the world playing as background to a peek
into Howard Dean’s upbringing courtesy of his mother’s
interview with the New York Times. The interview illustrates the hardships
this poor little rich boy experienced during the days of his youth. From
having to accept entitlements from his parents via manipulation of tax
loopholes to being subjected to the hostility of racism at the East Hampton
Maidstone Club, this exclusive glimpse into the childhood of this
Democratic presidential candidate is quite remarkable.
Andree Maitland Dean, Howard’s mother, goes to great lengths
to validate her son’s contention that his roots are "practically working
class.” In fact, it would seem that he was brought up with the same burden
that most working class people have to contend with, not treating the
servants like servants (Read as Mr. Howell from Gilligan’s
Island: Oh Lovie! Get Gilligan. The ugliness of all of it
is driving me mad!). The fact that he even had servants sets him apart from
the vast majority of Americans. It would be incredibly naïve to consider
Howard Dean as being familiar with the issues of the working class simply
because he worked a construction job while on medical deferment from duty in
Vietnam. After all, there weren’t too many blue-collar workers transversing
the slopes in Aspen back then.
Neither were many of the members of the working class burdened with their
parents funneling massive amounts of money to them, especially long after
they had left the fold. While Dean’s parents were channeling nearly a
million dollars to him, some in increments as large as $200,000 at a time,
over the past two decades, decades that saw him trained and working as a
physician and some suggest a politician, those of the working class were
making sure to set up their 401(k) accounts correctly (if they could afford
to have one), going without all through the year so they could perhaps take
a family vacation and always fighting the worry that existed in the back of
their minds about tax time. The last thing most working class people were
doing during the time Dean was receiving his unearned stipends was trying to
manipulate tax loopholes so they could add huge sums of fortune to their
portfolios while they raked in a physician’s salary. With this type of
financial upbringing it is easy to see why Dean is so eager to raise the
taxes on the middle class by repealing the Bush tax cuts.
But
probably the biggest hardship for Dean, the modern day version of the poor
little match girl from the early 20th Century, was having to summer at the
"whites only” Maidstone Club in the Hamptons. It must have been a
brutal experience, a humiliating experience, to be waited on by those who
weren’t even of the religion or race that would allow them to be members. I
would imagine that is where young Howard developed his sense of need for
diversity. It is quite obvious through the multi-cultural atmosphere that
exists in the post-Dean Vermont that this gross inequity weighed on his mind
quite heavily.
And then there was the traumatic experience of having to endure the horror
of racism at the Maidstone Club. As if the exclusion of people for
membership consideration based on their religion and/or the color of their
skin wasn’t startling enough, he had to endure the occasional racial epithet
from his own parents although he proclaims, "Yes, there was sort of this
casual racism, in terms of the racist expressions that were used by that
generation," he told the Times. "But in all, I think my family was pretty
open-minded about different kinds of people." I suppose when one summers in
the confines of the exclusive Maidstone Club one learns to be
tolerant of others, even if they are committing acts of racism, if only
casually.
For Howard Dean to stand in front of his supporters and the people of the
United States, grinning the grin of the snake oil salesman better than Bill
Clinton ever did, proclaiming that he "feels the pain” of the working class
people would be laughable if it weren’t so infuriating. The fact of the
matter, and it is quite apparent, is that Dean lived a life of privilege
equal to, if not more so than, anyone who is elected to office today. His
parents afforded him an upper-class college education, an education that
left him a physician. He was deferred from military service because of a
"medical problem” so debilitating that he was able to ski in Aspen instead
of fighting in Danang. He suffered the lavish brutality of the exclusive and
obviously racist Maidstone Club as he toiled his youthful summers
away and he learned that his brand of tolerance included an acceptable level
of racism.
If Howard Dean didn’t have the spin machine working overtime to quell those
who would point out these youthful "experiences”, one could argue he was
brought up a child of privilege, far from knowing the hardships of the
working class and whose values were akin to those of the Gatsbys,
the Vanderbilts and the Rockefellers. And it
doesn’t take a psychologist, an economist or even the talking heads of the
mainstream media who insist on ignoring these faux pas to explain to the
people of the United States that the Gatsbys, the Vanderbilts and the
Rockefellers, and evidently the Deans, were not working class.
The only question that remains to be answered about Howard Dean’s knowledge
of the working class is whether or not he has to remove the platinum spoon
before he engages the lavatory. Something tells me that's a problem for him.
Frank Salvato is a
political media consultant and the managing editor for The New Media Journal.us. He is a
contributing writer for The Washington Dispatch, GOPUSA, OpinionEditorials,
Men’s News Daily, Canada Free Press & AmericanDaily. His pieces are
regularly featured in Townhall.com. He has appeared as a guest on The
O’Reilly Factor, The Kevin Matthews Radio Show (Chicago) and The Brad Messer
Radio Show (San Antonio). His pieces have been recognized by the Japan
Center for Conflict Prevention and are occasionally featured in The
Washington Times and The London Morning Paper as well as other national and
international publications.
|